Notes on Honest John's Rating System

Recording Quality:  (of 4)

Noticeable hiss or hum or distortion  Noticeable hiss or hum or distortion -- Cassette quality.

 A digital recording of a live event.  A digital recording of a live event.   A digital recording of a live event.  An accurate representation of what the audience heard, but probably not what the performers wish the audience had heard.

A studio recording with some barely noticeable flawsA studio recording with some barely noticeable flawsA studio recording with some barely noticeable flaws  A studio recording with some barely noticeable flaws such as background traffic noise.

A virtually perfect studio recordingA virtually perfect studio recordingA virtually perfect studio recordingA virtually perfect studio recording  A virtually perfect studio recording.

Musical Performance: (of 5)

Many glaring problems  Many glaring problems such as singing out of tune, rhythmically not together, etc.

Occasional glaring problemsOccasional glaring problems  Occasional glaring problems as above.

Definitely amateur, with many subtle problems.Definitely amateur, with many subtle problems.Definitely amateur, with many subtle problems.   Definitely amateur, with many subtle problems.

Occasional and barely noticeable performance errorsOccasional and barely noticeable performance errorsOccasional and barely noticeable performance errorsOccasional and barely noticeable performance errors  Occasional and barely noticeable performance errors.

Professional in all regards.Professional in all regards.Professional in all regards.Professional in all regards.Professional in all regards.  Professional in all regards.